Molly O’Keefe’s Indecent Proposal

I have had many people tell me that Molly O’Keefe is a MUST read author that I would love. Though I Indecent Proposal over 18 months ago, I left it languishing in my TBR as I read other books. I finally managed to read it in February and it is so wonderful that I have proceeded to order in as many Molly O’Keefe books as I could find. But first, the blurb:


Screen Shot 2016-03-07 at 10.19.10 AMWith his chiseled jaw and thick blond hair, Harrison Montgomery was born to lead. Four generations of Montgomery men have served the state of Georgia, and now he’s next in line. Harrison, though, is driven to right wrongs: namely to clean up the political mess left by his father’s greed and corruption. But Harrison must first win his congressional bid, and nothing can get in his way—not even an angel who served him whiskey and gave him a shoulder to lean on and a body to love for a night. Problem is, she’s pregnant. Scandal is brewing, and there is only one solution: marriage.

Damage control? Ryan Kaminski can’t believe that a cold, calculating political animal now inhabits the body of the emotionally vulnerable stranger who gave her the most unforgettable night of her life. Really, she doesn’t want anything from Harrison, except to be left alone to have her baby in peace. But Ryan is broke, jobless, and essentially blackmailed by Harrison’s desperate family to accept this crazy marriage deal. For two years, she will have to act the role of caring, supportive wife. But what is Ryan supposed to do when she realizes that, deep in her heart, she’s falling in love?


This novel was ultra intense. Just like in category romances, the novel applies a microscopic focus on the events leading to two unlikely people coming together. Each pivotal scene changes their relationship trajectory is studied deeply and heavily. O’Keefe writes with such a depth of understanding her characters motivations that as the reader I felt engrossed in these two characters whose lives were led by lies that they had to perform either for themselves of for those around them.

Ryan and Harrison meet at the bar that Ryan works at. They hook-up that night and have heart-speeding and mind-blowing good sex. However, this is a case of no names, no phone numbers, no details so that they each go their own way with no chance of meeting again. Despite having used a condom, Ryan finds herself pregnant (and unemployed as her boss fires her as he takes issue with her sleeping with a patron of the bar). Her older brother, the only member of her family from whom she is not estranged, discovers the identity of her lover at the same time she does, as they are watching the news together when they find out that Harrison was a politician. In his big brother way and against Ryan’s wishes, he goes and insists that Harrison acknowledges Ryan to make sure she isn’t left in a tenuous position. What comes about is an awkward marriage purely to ensure that Harrison did not have to deal with a sex scandal during an election year. Harrison though is mired in scandal. He has a dodgy father whom he can’t abide, he is hiding his own secrets from a youth not misspent but misdirected in his first relationship. Ryan too is estranged from her family as her abusive ex-husband had stolen all of her father’s savings resulting in a six year exile. Ryan strikes upon a pre-nup with Harrison asking for her father’s mortgage to be paid off and in return she plays the supporting and loving politician’s wife. Loving in the public sphere yet separate in their private lives. But these two had an incredible connection right from the beginning of the book. One which after the initial tension of a forced marriage saw them blurring their public/private lives. Ryan and Harrison like each other. They understand each other and what they eventually discover is that the reason they worked so well in their public appearances is that it was the only place they could drop their pretense. The two turn to each other not only for sex but for comfort and affection, Ryan offering Harrison a hug as he is trying to deal with his own difficult days.

I liked this book. I liked the way that O’Keefe had each of these characters supporting each other. Each of their families were in equal parts dysfunctional and loving (if you could call Harrison’s tigress-defending-her-cubs mother loving). I love that O’Keefe managed to not demonise their dysfunctionality but shows that people are complex. Just because someone has crossed a societal “moral” line, does not make them a bad person and we see this with Harrison’s father Ted. At the same time, we see Ryan, who having been torn to shreds by Harrison rushes to her family home – a sign that if going to a place that has shunned her for 6 years is better than the reality of staying with him then their marriage was really going a bad way. Ryan has an awkward reconciliation with her family for how can she move forward with the father that she loves but who had not reached out to her during the six difficult years alone. Harrison though can’t live without Ryan for more than a day and he chases her down to convince her to stay with him.

Like Miss Bates (read her AMAZING review here), I got caught up in my reading of this book during a sleepless night. The humidity awakened me but Ryan and Harrison’s quandry kept me from falling back to sleep. So with my brand new night light, I read from 3am to 6am caught up in the emotions of this book. I shed a tear or two for Ryan who seemed rejected from all with whom she wanted to have a connection and my heart went out to Harrison who had the outward signs of success but was isolated and alone in his internal life until Ryan came along and connected with him. This book was all very emotional for me. It was intense and I highly recommend this complex and fabulous book.


I purchased my own copy of this book from an overseas online book vendor.



4 thoughts on “Molly O’Keefe’s Indecent Proposal

  1. *waves*! Thanks for MissB’s shout-out!! 🙂

    I love O’Keefe. I hope I was one of the people who insisted you read her. I love her categories and I love her longer books. And I’m always in awe of what she can do with the basic skeleton of the romance narrative. She fills it in and twists and turns it like an artist before a canvas. Of the four novels in the Boys of Bishop series, I think Between the Sheets is my favourite, for purely selfish and personal reasons. I’ve been that heroine. I understand everything about her. And the hero is one of my favourite heroes of all time. My absolute favourite of all her books is Crazy Thing Called Love (the final novel in the Crooked Creek Ranch series): reunited husband-and-wife Billy and Maddie are so broken and so strong at the same time. Their backstory and their forestory are perfect. I hope you read and write about them. *crosses all digits*

    • You were one of the people that insisted I read her! I will look out for the titles that you mention. My library had 2 of her categories which I will hopefully get to read soon.

      As for her writing! WOW! Her scenes continue to play in my mind even a month after I finished reading!

  2. Ooh – this one sounds REALLY GOOD! I am scurrying off to purchase it immediately. Isn’t her writing amazing? I don’t know how she does it – at a distance it just looks like any old writing, but then a sentence, a paragraph, a scene suddenly lights up and makes me catch my breath…and I’m wondering why I ever thought her writing was any old writing!
    (ps: I love your new look! 🙂

    • I have a TBR subset just for her books! And ta for the new look comment. I was going spare looking at my prior design but I am not wholly convinced that I like my new header either. I will play around with the look so watch this space!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s